Abstract 1715P
Background
Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) are usually considered the highest level of evidence for clinical practice. Patients assigned to control arm in RCTs should always receive the best available treatments to protect participants while also allowing for proper interpretation and applicability of study results. Here we analyzed RCTs published in oncology between 2017 and 2021, to describe the frequency of suboptimal control arms.
Methods
We identified phase III studies testing active treatments in patients with solid tumors among 11 major oncology journals. Each control arm was analyzed, and the standard of care was determined according to international guidelines and scientific evidence at accrual beginning and until accrual completion. We identified studies with suboptimal control arm from the beginning (type 1) and studies with an initially optimal control arm which became outdated during the accrual period (type 2).
Results
This analysis included 387 studies. 43 (11.1%) control arms were judged as suboptimal: 24 (6.2%) type 1 and 19 (4.9%) type 2. Suboptimality rates were higher in industry-sponsored compared to academic trials: 9.3% vs 1.9% for type 1 (p=0.003); 7.9% vs 0.6% for type 2 (p= 0.001). Suboptimality rates were higher in studies with positive results: 8.1% vs 4.0% for type 1 (p=0.09); 7.6% vs 1.7% for type 2 (p=0.007).
Conclusions
A non-negligible percentage of control arms, even in journals with high impact factor, was suboptimal according to our criteria. Many patients were treated with suboptimal control treatments in those trials, and the interpretation and applicability of study results can be challenging.
Clinical trial identification
Editorial acknowledgement
Legal entity responsible for the study
The authors.
Funding
Has not received any funding.
Disclosure
All authors have declared no conflicts of interest.
Resources from the same session
1912TiP - STELLAR-304: A randomized phase III study of zanzalintinib (XL092) and nivolumab in non-clear cell renal cell carcinoma (nccRCC)
Presenter: Sumanta Pal
Session: Poster session 23
2366P - Phase I-II study of niraparib plus cabozantinib in patients with advanced urothelial/kidney cancer (NICARAGUA trial)
Presenter: Daniel Castellano Gauna
Session: Poster session 23
2367P - A randomized phase II study of atezolizumab (atezo) plus recombinant human IL-7 (CYT107) vs. atezo alone in patients with locally advanced or metastatic urothelial carcinoma (mUC)
Presenter: Russells Pachynski
Session: Poster session 23
2368P - Activity of cabozantinib (CABO) plus durvalumab (DURVA) in patients (pts) with advanced non-urothelial-carcinoma variant histologies (VHs) or urothelial carcinoma (UC) after platinum-based chemotherapy: Interim results from the phase II ARCADIA trial
Presenter: Patrizia Giannatempo
Session: Poster session 23
2369P - Phase II study of nivolumab (nivo) and ipilimumab (ipi) for advanced bladder cancer with variant histologies (BCVH)
Presenter: Bradley McGregor
Session: Poster session 23
2370P - Updated results of PEANUT trial: Pembrolizumab and nab-paclitaxel as salvage therapy for platinum-treated, locally advanced or metastatic urothelial carcinoma (mUC)
Presenter: Achille Bottiglieri
Session: Poster session 23
2371P - Avelumab first-line (1L) maintenance for advanced urothelial carcinoma (aUC): Long-term outcomes from the JAVELIN Bladder 100 trial in older patients (pts)
Presenter: Shilpa Gupta
Session: Poster session 23
2372P - Efficacy of a tailored approach with nivolumab (N) and nivolumab+ipilimumab (N+I) as immuno-therapeutic boost in metastatic urothelial carcinoma (mUC): Final results of TITAN-TCC
Presenter: Marc-Oliver Grimm
Session: Poster session 23
2373P - Outcomes by retrospective eligibility for maintenance therapy of patients (pts) with advanced urothelial carcinoma (UC): Post hoc analysis of KEYNOTE-361
Presenter: Ronac Mamtani
Session: Poster session 23
2374P - A phase Ib single-arm trial of bintrafusp alfa (BA) for pretreated, locally advanced/unresectable or metastatic (advanced) urothelial cancer (aUC)
Presenter: Petros Grivas
Session: Poster session 23