Abstract 1312
Background
Predictive online calculators are used by clinicians as decision aids in early breast cancer (EBC). While use statistics for these calculators have not been published, as of 2017 NHS Predict was being accessed more than 20,000 times a month. These predictive tools have not had accuracy & benefit of use prospectively confirmed in EBC, yet use of calculators has been encouraged in EBC guidelines. It is important to understand the populations informing model development & validation, to understand how data bias may impact predictions in under-represented subpopulations. This work sought to elucidate the risk of bias in model development & validation for 3 online EBC calculators (NHS Predict, Adjuvant! & Cancermath), in an effort to highlight sub-populations where calculated risk & therefore treatment benefit estimates may be less reliable.
Methods
A literature search was conducted in PubMed, search terms were “predict*” “adjuvant” “breast” & “algorithm”. Results were screened for relevance to the three predictive tools under scrutiny & additional references were extracted from relevant papers. Using a modified CHARMS checklist, the relevant sections of the development & validation papers were extracted.
Results
6 development & 24 validation papers were reviewed as summarised in the TableTable:
264P
Predict | Adjuvant | Cancermath | |
---|---|---|---|
Development population size & date range | 5694 1977-2008 | 37,968 1977-2007 | 499,724 1977-2007 |
Aged <35 in development population | 2% (111) | 0 | >0.5% |
Aged >65 in development population | 32% (1781) | 0 | >17% |
Tumour size >5cm in development population | 5% (287) | 0 | 0 |
Number of validation studies | 10 | 13 | 3 |
% retrospective | 100 | 100 | 100 |
Total number of patients in validation studies | 19,864 | 19,618 | 11,203 |
Age >65 in validations | 35% (7134) | 42% (8313) | 40% (4519) |
Age <35 in validations | 16% (3235) | 8% (1518) | 9% (1007) |
Tumour size >5cm in validations | 5% (287) | 5% (1015) | 6% (634) |
Universal exclusions | Multi-focal, inflammatory, male | Multi-focal, inflammatory, male | Multi-focal, inflammatory, male |
Neoadjuvant chemotherapy not an exclusion | 1 study (121 patients) | 0 | 0 |
Overall conclusions of validation authors | Earlier versions under-predicted mortality in women <35 Poor performance in tumours >5cm. | Poor performance in general in: <35 and >65 More advanced disease Malay ethnicity Overly optimistic survival predictions across subgroups in UK population. | Poor performance in < 35 Systematically under-predicted mortality, especially for ER-negative tumours. |
Conclusions
All 3 predictive tools have under-represented groups in their development cohorts, specifically those under 35 & over 65 years old, as well as larger tumours. Validation studies consistently demonstrate worse performance in these groups. However, due to inconsistent methodology in validation studies, quantitating the summary performance within & across tools is difficult. These predictive tools should be used with caution in under-represented populations. More work is required to look at clinical utility of tools as well as their statistical performance.
Clinical trial identification
Editorial acknowledgement
Legal entity responsible for the study
The authors.
Funding
Has not received any funding.
Disclosure
All authors have declared no conflicts of interest.
Resources from the same session
4022 - Ribociclib (RIB) plus letrozole (LET) in male patients (pts) with hormone receptor-positive (HR+), human epidermal growth factor receptor-2–negative (HER2–) advanced breast cancer (ABC) from the CompLEEment-1 trial
Presenter: Mario Campone
Session: Poster Display session 2
Resources:
Abstract
3599 - Comparative effectiveness of palbociclib plus letrozole vs letrozole for metastatic breast cancer in US real-world clinical practices
Presenter: Rachel Layman
Session: Poster Display session 2
Resources:
Abstract
901 - Pharmacokinetics (PK), safety, and efficacy of [fam-] trastuzumab deruxtecan with OATP1B/CYP3A inhibitors in subjects with HER2-expressing advanced solid tumors
Presenter: Yung-Jue Bang
Session: Poster Display session 2
Resources:
Abstract
2777 - A Phase 2 study of abemaciclib in patients (pts) with brain metastases (BM) secondary to non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) or melanoma (MEL).
Presenter: Solmaz Sahebjam
Session: Poster Display session 2
Resources:
Abstract
3980 - Ribociclib (RIB) + letrozole (LET) in patients (pts) with visceral metastases (VM) or bone-only metastases (BOM) in hormone receptor-positive (HR+), human epidermal growth factor receptor-2–negative (HER2–) advanced breast cancer (ABC): Subgroup analysis from the CompLEEment-1 trial
Presenter: Michelino De Laurentiis
Session: Poster Display session 2
Resources:
Abstract
4024 - Ribociclib (RIB) + letrozole (LET) in patients (pts) with hormone receptor-positive (HR+), human epidermal growth factor receptor-2–negative (HER2–) advanced breast cancer (ABC) and central nervous system (CNS) metastases: Subgroup analysis from the phase 3b CompLEEment-1 trial
Presenter: Paul Cottu
Session: Poster Display session 2
Resources:
Abstract
2151 - Clinical outcome and toxicity data in patients with advanced breast cancer treated with cyclin-dependent kinase 4/6 (CDK4/6) inhibitors combined with endocrine therapy in a real-world clinical setting.
Presenter: Elena Fountzilas
Session: Poster Display session 2
Resources:
Abstract
3994 - Safety and efficacy of Ribociclib (RIBO) + letrozole (LET) in patients (pts) with hormone receptor-positive (HR+), human epidermal growth factor receptor 2-negative (HER2–) advanced breast cancer (ABC): Interim results from the Italian cohort of the CompLEEment-1 (C-1) study.
Presenter: Michele De Laurentiis
Session: Poster Display session 2
Resources:
Abstract
1370 - Interim Results From CompLEEment-1 (A Phase 3b Study of Ribociclib and Letrozole as First-Line Therapy for Advanced Breast Cancer in an Expanded Population): Spanish cohort results
Presenter: Javier Salvador
Session: Poster Display session 2
Resources:
Abstract
1109 - First Canadian Interim Analysis from the Phase IIIb CompLEEment-1 Ribociclib + Letrozole HR+ HER2- Advanced Breast Cancer Trial
Presenter: Cristiano Ferrario
Session: Poster Display session 2
Resources:
Abstract