Abstract 5783
Background
Six anti–PD-1/PD-L1 agents have been FDA approved for various cancers. Despite a lack of head-to-head trials, there is a perception that the irAE profiles are comparable between agents. We hypothesized that the irAE profiles vary between anti–PD-1 and anti–PD-L1 agents and among individual agents. Since prospective comparison is unlikely, we conducted a trial-level meta-analysis of irAEs reported in phase I–IV trials evaluating anti–PD-1/L1 agents in various tumor types.
Methods
We analyzed data from 35 manuscripts reporting phase I (n = 18), 2 (n = 15), 3 (n = 9) or 4 (n = 1) trials, comprising 8,730 patients treated with anti–PD-1/PD-L1 monotherapy. The incidence and odds ratios (ORs) for selected clinically relevant irAEs (colitis, elevated AST, hypothyroidism, pneumonitis or rash; any grade and grade ≥3) and irAEs overall were estimated using random-effects models for anti–PD-L1 agents atezolizumab, avelumab and durvalumab; for anti–PD-1 agents nivolumab and pembrolizumab; and as pooled estimates for anti–PD-1 and anti–PD-L1 agents.
Results
The risk of any grade (OR = 4.34) and grade ≥3 rash (OR = 4.38); grade ≥3 hypothyroidism (OR = 2.85); any grade (OR = 2.53) and grade ≥3 colitis (OR = 3.79); and any grade ≥3 irAE (OR = 1.89) was higher with anti–PD-1 vs anti–PD-L1 agents. When comparing the risk of all selected irAEs for each agent with pooled estimates for all other agents combined, atezolizumab had the lowest risk, followed by avelumab; pembrolizumab had a higher risk, except for grade ≥3 elevated AST. In pairwise comparisons, the risks associated with atezolizumab vs avelumab were not significantly different, likewise for nivolumab vs pembrolizumab. The largest decrease in risk for all grade ≥3 irAEs except elevated AST was for avelumab vs pembrolizumab.
Conclusions
Overall, the risk of grade ≥3 irAEs was higher with anti–PD-1 vs anti–PD-L1 agents. Compared with other agents, avelumab had a lower risk of individual grade ≥3 irAEs except elevated AST, whereas atezolizumab had the lowest risk of irAEs of any grade. Limitations include the retrospective nature of the meta-analysis and varied tumor types, trial designs, treatment durations and irAE evaluations.
Clinical trial identification
Editorial acknowledgement
ClinicalThinking, funded by Merck Healthcare KGaA and Pfizer Inc.
Legal entity responsible for the study
Merck Healthcare KGaA.
Funding
Merck Healthcare KGaA and Pfizer Inc.
Disclosure
G.P. Sonpavde: Honoraria (self): UpToDate; Advisory / Consultancy: Agensys; Advisory / Consultancy: Astellas Pharma; Advisory / Consultancy: AstraZeneca; Advisory / Consultancy, Research grant / Funding (institution): Bayer; Advisory / Consultancy, Research grant / Funding (institution): Bristol-Myers Squibb; Advisory / Consultancy: Eisai; Advisory / Consultancy: EMD Serono; Advisory / Consultancy: Exelixis; Advisory / Consultancy: Genentech; Advisory / Consultancy, Research grant / Funding (institution): Janssen; Advisory / Consultancy, Research grant / Funding (institution): Merck & Co.; Advisory / Consultancy: Novartis; Advisory / Consultancy, Research grant / Funding (institution): Sanofi; Speaker Bureau / Expert testimony: Clinical Care Options/NCCN; Speaker Bureau / Expert testimony: Onclive; Speaker Bureau / Expert testimony: Physician Education Resource; Speaker Bureau / Expert testimony: Research to Practice; Research grant / Funding (institution): Boehringer Ingelheim; Research grant / Funding (institution): Celgene; Research grant / Funding (institution): Onyx; Research grant / Funding (institution): Pfizer. P. Grivas: Advisory / Consultancy, Research grant / Funding (institution): AstraZeneca; Advisory / Consultancy: Biocept; Advisory / Consultancy, Speaker Bureau / Expert testimony: Bristol-Myers Squibb; Advisory / Consultancy, Research grant / Funding (institution): Clovis Oncology; Advisory / Consultancy: Driver, Inc; Advisory / Consultancy: EMD Serono; Advisory / Consultancy: Foundation Medicine; Advisory / Consultancy, Speaker Bureau / Expert testimony, Research grant / Funding (institution): Genentech/Roche; Advisory / Consultancy: Heron; Advisory / Consultancy, Research grant / Funding (institution): Merck & Co.; Advisory / Consultancy, Research grant / Funding (institution): Pfizer; Advisory / Consultancy: QED Therapeutics; Advisory / Consultancy: Seattle Genetics; Research grant / Funding (institution): Bayer; Research grant / Funding (institution): Mirati Therapeutics; Research grant / Funding (institution): Oncogenex. D. Hennessy: Full / Part-time employment: EMD Serono. J.D. Hunt: Full / Part-time employment: EMD Serono. All other authors have declared no conflicts of interest.
Resources from the same session
5043 - Comprehensive results of a Phase Ib study with a HER2/neu B-cell peptide vaccine administered with cisplatin and 5-fluorouracil or capecitabine chemotherapy show safety, immunogenicity and clinical response in patients with HER2/Neu overexpressing advanced gastric cancer
Presenter: Ursula Wiedermann
Session: Poster Display session 3
Resources:
Abstract
4506 - Single intravenous preoperative administration of the oncolytic virus Pexa-Vec to prime anti-tumor immunity
Presenter: Adel Samson
Session: Poster Display session 3
Resources:
Abstract
1631 - Randomized phase 2 clinical trial of NY-ESO-1 protein vaccine combined with cholesteryl pullulan (CHP-NY-ESO-1) in resected esophageal cancer patients
Presenter: Shinichi Kageyama
Session: Poster Display session 3
Resources:
Abstract
4244 - T cell repertoire sequencing reveals dynamics of response to dendritic cell vaccine plus dasatinib for checkpoint blockade resistant metastatic melanoma
Presenter: Luca Quagliata
Session: Poster Display session 3
Resources:
Abstract
5791 - Ixovex, a novel oncolytic E1B-mutated adenovirus
Presenter: Mohiemen Anwar
Session: Poster Display session 3
Resources:
Abstract
4170 - Anti-CSPG4 DNA vaccination as a promising strategy for the treatment of CSPG4+ tumors: a comparative oncology trial
Presenter: Federica Riccardo
Session: Poster Display session 3
Resources:
Abstract
5780 - Antitumor activity, immunogenicity and safety of a novel PD-1 vaccine in combination with two chimeric HER-2 peptide vaccine in syngeneic Balb/c, C57Bl/6 models and in beagle dogs
Presenter: Pravin Kaumaya
Session: Poster Display session 3
Resources:
Abstract
5860 - Maternal immunization against ALK as a weapon to fight neuroblastoma
Presenter: Giuseppina Barutello
Session: Poster Display session 3
Resources:
Abstract
4720 - Phase 1 study evaluating safety, pharmacokinetics (PK), pharmacodynamics, and preliminary efficacy of ABBV-428, first-in-class mesothelin (MSLN)-CD40 bispecific, in patients (pts) with advanced solid tumors
Presenter: Jason Luke
Session: Poster Display session 3
Resources:
Abstract
5717 - Anti-PD-L1/IL-15 fusion protein generates robust adaptive immune gene signatures in tumors leading to tumor inhibition and memory responses
Presenter: Stella Martomo
Session: Poster Display session 3
Resources:
Abstract